Brookside Surplus

Brookside Surplus in Sugarcreek, OH, offers a delightful experience that feels like a treasure hunt every time you walk through the door. With an impressive 4.8-star rating from nearly 100 reviews, it’s no wonder that locals and visitors alike sing its praises. As Craig noted, this store is operated by friendly Amish staff who create a welcoming atmosphere that makes shopping here a joy. Customers love the variety of products, from canned goods to quirky merchandise, with many leaving with boxes full of goodies for under $50!

Abby H perfectly captured the sentiment when she said, 'I love this place by far my favorite around.' The consistent friendliness of the staff is a major highlight, as multiple reviewers echoed the sentiment of being greeted with smiles and warmth. Kimberly Kroninger’s experience reflects this, sharing how she and her daughter were thrilled with their haul, "Box full under $50.00! Very friendly staff! Loved it!! We will be back!!!" However, not every experience is perfect; some shoppers noted occasional inventory inconsistencies, where specific items they hoped to find weren’t available.

Perhaps the most heartwarming story comes from Candi Felker, who shared how the staff went above and beyond to assist her with mobility issues. This reflects the genuine care that seems to radiate from Brookside Surplus, making it a must-visit spot in Amish country. While the product selection is diverse, remember that it may vary, so make a plan but keep an open mind!