The Bargain Shoppe
Closed
About The Bargain Shoppe
The Bargain Shoppe is a delightful gift shop located in Lily Dale, New York, offering a unique selection of trinkets, baubles, and special occasion gifts. With a focus on unique and meaningful items, it’s a great spot to find something special for yourself or a loved one.
The shop has a charming atmosphere, often enhanced by the occasional visit from a local cat, which adds a cozy and welcoming vibe. Customers appreciate the friendly service and the wide variety of products available, making it a pleasant place to browse.
Situated in the heart of Lily Dale, The Bargain Shoppe is easily accessible for both locals and visitors. The shop's convenient hours make it easy to stop by, whether you're exploring the town or looking for a quick gift.
Editor's Review
The Bargain Shoppe in Lily Dale, New York, has carved out a charming niche for itself, winning the hearts of many visitors with its eclectic offerings and warm atmosphere. With an impressive overall rating of 4.7 out of 5, the store serves as a delightful stop for anyone in search of unique gifts, trinkets, or even a little something special for themselves. As Kris Z noted, 'There’s definitely something here for everybody, for any occasion,' emphasizing the shop's diverse selection that includes everything from dreamcatchers to polished stones.
However, it’s not all sunshine and rainbows. While many customers praise the owner, Bob, for his friendliness and knowledge, some have encountered issues with service. A frustrating experience shared by Castar Waide highlighted an unkind interaction when seeking information about a product. Another reviewer, Phoebe Nelson, expressed disappointment after driving thirty minutes only to find the shop closed earlier than expected. Despite these hiccups, the consensus remains largely positive.
Ultimately, The Bargain Shoppe stands out not just for its offerings, but also for the stories and experiences it provides. It’s a place where visitors often leave with more than just a purchase; they take with them a piece of local charm and perhaps even a memory of a friendly cat that sometimes wanders into the shop.
What We Like
- Wide variety of unique gifts and trinkets
- Friendly and knowledgeable staff, especially Bob
- Charming atmosphere with opportunities for fun local stories
Room for Improvement
- Inconsistent customer service experiences
- Occasional discrepancies in posted hours
What Customers Are Saying
“There's definitely something here for everybody, for any occasion.”
— Kris Z (ZiggyZ)
“Bob is very knowledgeable and friendly. Thank you for being there when no one else is.”
— Diane Tyma
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“There's definitely something here for everybody”
“Bob is very knowledgeable and friendly”
“I was so disappointed to find it closed at 4pm”
Insider Tips
Check the store hours before visiting
Call ahead if looking for specific items
What to Expect
- Expect a warm and inviting shopping experience with friendly staff ready to assist you.
- You'll find a diverse range of products suitable for various occasions, ensuring there's something for everyone.
- Prices are generally accessible, making it easy to find a gift that fits your budget.
Google Reviews
Cute little shop. Fairly wide selection of trinkets and baubles. Found out that sometimes a cat from down the street visits and hangs out from time to time. Owner told us that the cat's older sibling spent 11 years hanging out at the shop.
I bought my friend a pendant, one of the celtic porcelain pendants, and she recently passed. I was trying to find the brand so I could look up a picture to ask her family to save it for me. The person on the phone was incredibly unkind and hung up on...
There's definitely something here for everybody, for any occasion, whether it's a neat little unique gift for someone you know or even for yourself, no matter what it is that you like or may be into. You'll Probably even find something new that perks...
I love this shop and always visit whenever in the area. On our most recent visit, though, I was so disappointed to drive 30 minutes out of our way to stop in and find it closed at 4pm, despite all displayed hours online saying it was open every day t...
Absolutely one of the best places in The Dale. Bob is very knowledgable and friendly. Thank you for being there when no one else is. This shop is open all year long. You are a true Blessing! 💜❤
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
If you're a first-time visitor, take your time to explore the shop as there are many unique items to discover.
Consider visiting during the early afternoon to avoid busier times and have a more relaxed shopping experience.
There are parking options nearby, so you won't have to worry about finding a spot when you visit.
Hours
- monday11:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- tuesday11:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- wednesday11:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- thursday11:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- friday11:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- saturday11:00 AM - 4:00 PM
- sunday11:00 AM - 4:00 PM


