Pick 'n Save
Open Now
About Pick 'n Save
Pick 'n Save in Pewaukee, Wisconsin, is a grocery store that offers a wide range of products at discounted prices, making it an excellent option for budget-conscious shoppers. The store focuses on providing quality groceries, including fresh produce, pantry staples, and household items, often at lower prices than traditional grocery outlets.
The atmosphere at Pick 'n Save is friendly and welcoming, with staff members who are described as helpful and knowledgeable. Customers have noted the store's cleanliness and organization, which contributes to a pleasant shopping experience, whether you're filling a cart or picking up an order.
Located conveniently in Pewaukee, Pick 'n Save is easily accessible for local residents. The store's layout allows for easy navigation, and it offers ample parking, making it a practical choice for grocery shopping without the hassle.
Editor's Review
Pick 'n Save in Pewaukee, Wisconsin, gets a mixed bag of reviews, and here's what nobody tells you: it can be a hit or miss. Some customers rave about the friendly staff and the freshness of the products, while others complain about service issues. For instance, Robert Stuart Mitchell praises the helpful and cheerful store attendants, stating, 'Personally, I've never had a bad experience here.' But the complaints about self-checkout staffing are hard to ignore. Kelly Cole-Cannon’s experience highlights a significant gap in service when she said, 'Now they use Instacart, and they are HORRIBLE.'
While the website for ordering is straightforward, as Al Reich noted, 'Simple web site for ordering, pick-up time was communicated perfectly,' the inconsistency in service can throw a wrench in the whole shopping experience. Many reviewers mention that store hours can be frustrating, especially when only self-checkout is open during peak hours.
What stands out is the quality of perishable items, backed by multiple positive remarks about freshness. However, be prepared for potential hiccups with service. Customers seem to either love or hate this place, depending on their luck with the staff and checkout experiences.
What We Like
- Friendly and knowledgeable staff
- Fresh produce and quality items
- Convenient ordering and communication
Room for Improvement
- Self-checkout can be frustrating with limited staff
- Inconsistent service experiences
- Delivery service issues reported
What Customers Are Saying
“'Overall - Sensational experience! I'm 79 years old and for a larger order..... online is fabulous. Thanks!'”
— Al Reich
“'REALLY ANNOYING IS THERE'S TWO EMPLOYEES STANDING AT SELF CHECKOUT WATCHING YOU. You should get a discount if you are doing an employee's job.'”
— Cruising the area
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
“Now they use Instacart, and they are HORRIBLE.”
“The managers are friendly and sharp.”
“Simple web site for ordering, pick-up time was communicated perfectly.”
“Perishable items are always fresh.”
“Alittle frustrating when you go early to shop and all that's open is the self checkout.”
Insider Tips
Use delivery if available, but check provider reviews
Shop during regular hours to avoid self-checkout only
Expect friendly service from staff
What to Expect
- Expect a friendly shopping experience with helpful staff ready to assist you.
- You'll find a diverse selection of grocery items at discounted prices.
- Shopping at Pick 'n Save offers great value, especially for those looking to save on their grocery bills.
Google Reviews
I used to love using Kroger home delivery because I'm permanently disabled and it made shopping convenient. As of this month (January) Kroger got rid of their delivery trucks. That was one of the main reasons I went with them instead of a different s...
Simple web site for ordering, pick-up time was communicated perfectly, and the guy that delivered my order to the car was polite and professional. Overall - Sensational experience! 🥰 I'm 79 years old and for a larger order..... online is fabulous. ...
Personally, I've never had a bad experience here. The managers are friendly and sharp, and all the attendants and stockers are helpful, knowledgeable, and cheerful. The product choices always seem wide and varied, perishable items are always fresh, a...
On Christmas Eve 2025, I was short $100 on my $280 lottery winnings, which I cashed in at the Pewaukee Pick and Save. I called the store and they told me to call back on the 26th of December cause they would not know their cash tiller results until t...
Alittle frustrating when you go early to shop and all that's open is the self checkout. REALLY ANNOYING IS THERE'S TWO EMPLOYEES STANDING AT SELF CHECKOUT WATCHING YOU. You should get a discount if you are doing an employee's job. We need Schnucks ...
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
Consider visiting during non-peak hours, such as early mornings or late evenings, for a quieter shopping experience.
Take advantage of any online ordering options for easier pick-up if you're in a hurry.
Check out nearby stores or restaurants if you're planning to make a day of it in the Pewaukee area.
Hours
- monday6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- tuesday6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- wednesday6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- thursday6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- friday6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- saturday6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
- sunday6:00 AM - 10:00 PM
