Bargain Center
Closed
About Bargain Center
Bargain Center in Montgomery, Indiana, is a unique grocery store that offers a wide range of products at discounted prices, making it a go-to spot for budget-conscious shoppers. Known locally as the 'Amish Walmart', it features an assortment of items that are often hard to find in conventional grocery stores.
The atmosphere at Bargain Center is welcoming and friendly, with a beautifully designed new building that enhances the shopping experience. Customers often praise the store for its spacious layout, making it easy to navigate through the aisles filled with an array of grocery items, including fresh lunch meats and cheeses.
Conveniently located in Montgomery, this grocery store is easily accessible for both locals and visitors. Ample parking is available, allowing for a hassle-free visit whether you're stopping by for a quick shopping trip or planning to browse through their extensive selection.
Editor's Review
Bargain Center in Montgomery, Indiana, is gaining a reputation as a local favorite, affectionately dubbed the 'Amish Walmart.' Shoppers appreciate the wide variety of ingredients, especially for cooking and baking, which are often hard to find elsewhere. As Chris Lee pointed out, 'This place is known affectionately by the locals as 'Amish Walmart'. It is a great place to find things you just can't find in most retail grocery stores.'
The new location, touted as larger and better than the old one lost to a fire, has drawn praise for its cleanliness and friendly staff. A S praised its 'beautiful new building' and noted, 'Great Amish grocery store with some deals!' Customers often highlight the deli, which offers mouthwatering sandwiches and a selection of lunch meats and cheeses.
However, the reviews do reveal some concerns. Pricing has become a talking point; Tammy Butler noted that prices are 'quite expensive compared to before the fire.' Additionally, some shoppers feel the spice selection hasn't fully returned to what it once was. On a positive note, staff are reportedly working on expanding their offerings to include more spices.
In summary, if you need decent ingredients at competitive prices in a friendly atmosphere, Bargain Center is worth checking out. But be prepared for a few bumps as they continue to rebuild their inventory.
What We Like
- Large variety of cooking and baking ingredients
- Friendly and helpful staff
- Clean and spacious new building
Room for Improvement
- Higher prices compared to the previous store
- Limited selection of spices currently
What Customers Are Saying
βThis place is known affectionately by the locals as 'Amish Walmart'.β
β Chris Lee
βBeautiful new building. Great Amish grocery store with some deals!β
β A S
βI really wish they would put how to use their donut and bread mixes.β
β Tammy Butler
What Shoppers Say
Based on analysis of 5 customer reviews
βNot as big of a selection of spices as beforeβ
βQuite expensive compared to before the fireβ
βThe store is kept cleanβ
βThe staff are very friendlyβ
βAwesome lunch meat and cheesesβ
Insider Tips
Check for new products as they are still adding shelves
Look for recipes on product labels for baking mixes
What to Expect
- Expect a friendly shopping environment with helpful staff ready to assist you.
- You'll find a diverse selection of products, especially local Amish goods, that cater to various culinary needs.
- Pricing is competitive, making it a great option for those looking to save money on groceries.
Google Reviews
This place is known affectionately by the locals as "Amish Walmart". It is a great place to find things you just can't find in most retails grocery stores. Here you can get all of the ingredients you need to cook or bake just about anything. The pric...
Beautiful new building. Great Amish grocery store with some deals!
Owsom lunch meat and cheeses it's even bigger now than it was take a stroll down the baking and spices isle
Was surprised at the prices now, quite expensive compared to before the fire. Not as big of a selection of spices as before, but their still adding to the shelves. I really wish they would put how to use their donut and bread mixes, like the amish st...
The barga. In center is pretty cool.They got awesome sandwiches at the deli, but I'll tell you what. Knock knock who's there bull who....
Reviews from Google
Frequently Asked Questions
Visiting Tips
First-time visitors should take their time to explore the aisles as there are many hidden gems to discover.
Try to visit earlier in the day when the store is less crowded for a more relaxed shopping experience.
Look for nearby parking options, as the store is located in a convenient area with easy access.
Hours
- monday8:00β―AM - 5:00β―PM
- tuesday8:00β―AM - 5:00β―PM
- wednesday8:00β―AM - 5:00β―PM
- thursday8:00β―AM - 5:00β―PM
- friday8:00β―AM - 5:00β―PM
- saturday8:00β―AM - 3:00β―PM
- sundayClosed




